For too long, we Vatican II Catholics have understandably confused Roman Rite Catholicism with the Universal Catholic Church,
…mainly because Roman Rite Catholicism is internally confused about that one as well.
Vatican II, however, was definitely a rupture in that kind of confused thinking.
More than that, Vatican II was a rupture in the very theology that
…supports what Rome defines as bona fide Catholicism.
Meanwhile, Roman Catholicism has tried to quietly stitch together that rupture between
…Vatican II theology and RC theology with authoritative words
…like “continuity,” “tradition,” and “unity”.
The justifiable effort here was to spiritualize the aggiornamento (updating) of the Church …in order to save the Church from the “excesses” of Vatican II.
The unintended consequence of this action was to shut down /melt down Vatican II …into business (theology/governance/liturgy) as usual.
The Holy Spirit, however, was not to be shut out or melted down into business as usual.
Just as the first Pentecost was a rupture in the Judaic vision of itself, humanity and God,
…so was Vatican II a rupture in the Roman Church’s view of itself, God and the world
…a rupture in Roman Catholic Theology.
(Vatican II expert Richard Gaillardetz discusses “micro-ruptures evident in the teaching of Vatican II” in Boston College School of Theology video, “Fulfilling the Unrealized Vision of Vatican II”.)
With Vatican II, the Holy Spirit initiated a challenge to Roman Rite theology,
…as well as RC hierarchic style of governance and its liturgical/sacramental practice.
Vatican II also challenged the ROMAN Catholic vision of the Church
…as well as its concepts of Catholic identity and Catholic culture.
Any kind of rupture, even sacred micro-ruptures in theology alone;
…these were not the intent of Vatican II,
…but these ruptures were definitely the consequence of the Vatican II event.
The purpose of Vatican II was the updating of the Roman Catholic Church,
…and some cardinals/bishops didn’t even see the need for that.
The Holy Spirit had different ideas, inviting the Council to move in other directions
…right from the start
…as typified when the cardinals/bishops resisted
…the imposition of a curial-fixed agenda on the Council proceedings.
How often, the Holy Spirit calls us in one direction, only to take us off down a road we never expected, always with results beyond any we could ever have imagined.
As long as we delay the consummation of the inherent rupture in Roman Catholicism …caused by all the suppressed micro ruptures that Richard Gailliardetz describes,
…that much longer will we delay the action the Holy Spirit initiated
…at the Second Vatican Council.
The fact of the matter is that…
we NEED BOTH the Roman and Vatican II Rites of the Catholic Church,
…each for very different reasons…
just as we have need of the Eastern Catholic Rites
…and the very significant role they played in
…re-introducing synodality, collegiality and other reforms
…at the world-wide, Second Ecumenical Vatican Council.
Catholicism needs its many rites
…in order that we may challenge and learn from each other.
The unity of Catholicism is the miracle of a “separate yet one-with” diverse unity,
… an unimaginable oneness
…that can only be brought about by the divine intervention of the Holy Spirit.
So, you think maybe the Catholic Church NEEDS a Vatican II RITE in union with Rome?
Join the discussion! Subscribe to RITE BEYOND ROME. See, download and share this document for discussion with others. View Picture the Possibility of a Vatican II Rite